Home/Library/Explainer
ExplainerUpdated October 2026Estate litigationGermanyProbate
For heirs, legatees, personal representatives, trustees and their advisors

Trust and Estate Litigation across Borders

An estate with heirs or assets in Germany and the United States can be litigated in the courts of both countries at once, under different rules on jurisdiction, time limits and the recognition of judgments.

By Caroline Esche Ashford, PhD, JD · Law stated as of October 2026

A courthouse

Summary.

  1. Cross-border estate disputes concern wills, forced heirs’ claims such as the German Pflichtteil, trustees’ accounts and removal, and claims against personal representatives.
  2. For deaths on or after August 17, 2015, German courts decide the whole succession of a person habitually resident in Germany, and also of a German national habitually resident in the United States who left assets in Germany (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Articles 4, 10(1)(a) and 83(1)).
  3. The Regulation’s rule against parallel proceedings binds only courts of Member States, so a German and a US court can hear the same estate at once (Article 17(1)).
  4. Periods to contest a will are short: six months after published notice of the appointment in Washington DC, six months after the first appointment in Maryland, one year from the probate order in Virginia (D.C. Code § 20-305; Md. Code, Est. & Trusts § 5-207(a); Va. Code § 64.2-448(A)).
  5. A German forced heir has a money claim against the heirs for half the value of the intestate share, and gifts made within ten years before death are added back on a declining scale (§§ 2303, 2325 BGB).
  6. No treaty governs the recognition of judgments between Germany and the United States: a US judgment is recognized in Germany under § 328 ZPO, which requires reciprocity, and a German money judgment in Washington DC and Virginia under uniform statutes that do not.

Part I. The disputes that arise in cross-border estates

A cross-border estate dispute turns on the same questions as a domestic one: whether the will is valid, who takes and how much, and whether the fiduciaries have acted properly. Four groups recur. Will contests challenge the testator’s capacity, allege undue influence or attack the formal validity of the instrument. Forced heirs, such as a child entitled to the German compulsory share (Pflichtteil), claim against the heirs, including for the US assets. Beneficiaries dispute a trustee’s reports, investments and distributions or seek the trustee’s removal. Heirs and creditors bring claims against a personal representative for losses, delay or payments made in the wrong order.

What sets the cross-border case apart is procedure. Courts in two countries may each regard themselves as competent, each applies its own conflict rules, and a decision from one country takes effect in the other only under that country’s recognition rules. A will executed in the local form of one country can thus be valid there and still be questioned before a probate court in the other (see Estate Planning Differences between Continental Europe and the United States).

Part II. Which court decides in the United States

Succession proceedings in the United States are a matter of state law: the court of the domicile conducts the principal administration, and a state where real property lies conducts an ancillary proceeding for it. Will contests and disputes over a personal representative belong to the probate proceeding in the state concerned. A US court applies its own conflict rules and is not bound by a determination made under the EU Succession Regulation.

The three jurisdictions of the Washington region organize the contest differently. In Virginia, an interested person may appeal the clerk’s probate order to the circuit court within six months for a new hearing (Va. Code § 64.2-445), and a later complaint to impeach or establish the will is tried by a jury, which determines whether the document offered is the testator’s will (Va. Code § 64.2-448). In Maryland, a petition to caveat filed before probate or after administrative probate operates as a request for judicial probate, and one filed after judicial probate reopens the matter for a new proceeding (Md. Code, Est. & Trusts § 5-207(b)(1), (2)). In Washington DC, a will is contested by verified complaint, with notice to all interested persons (D.C. Code § 20-305).

Part III. Which court decides in Germany

For the succession of persons who die on or after August 17, 2015, German courts determine their jurisdiction under Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 (Article 83(1)). The courts of the Member State in which the deceased had his or her habitual residence at death have jurisdiction over the succession as a whole (Article 4). Where the habitual residence was outside the Member States, the courts of a Member State in which estate assets are located still have jurisdiction over the whole succession if the deceased was a national of that State or, failing that, had a previous habitual residence there that ended not more than five years before the court was seised (Article 10(1)). Otherwise they decide only on the assets located there (Article 10(2)).

A German national who lived in Virginia and left an account in Munich thus leaves German courts with jurisdiction over the entire estate, the Virginia house included; a US citizen with no German nationality or recent German residence, over the German assets alone. In Germany these matters come before the probate court (Nachlassgericht), which issues the certificate of inheritance (Erbschein) (§ 2353 BGB), and before the civil courts for contested claims such as a Pflichtteil claim.

Two provisions limit the reach of this jurisdiction in practice. On the application of a party, the court may decline to rule on assets located in a third State such as the United States where its decision is not expected to be recognized there (Article 12(1)). And the rule requiring a court seised second to stay its proceedings applies only to proceedings in the courts of different Member States (Article 17(1)), so it does not prevent a German proceeding and a US proceeding on the same estate from running in parallel.

Part IV. Time limits to contest a will in Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia

In each of the three US jurisdictions the period to contest a will is measured from an event in the probate proceeding, not from the date on which an heir abroad learns of it. In Washington DC, a verified complaint to contest a will must be filed within six months following notice by publication of the appointment or reappointment of a personal representative, subject to the provision for small estates (D.C. Code § 20-305). Within the same six months an interested person may have an abbreviated probate set aside by requesting formal probate, and a formal proceeding may be reopened on grounds that include lack of notice and a later-discovered will (D.C. Code § 20-331(a), (b)).

In Maryland, a verified petition to caveat a will may be filed, whether or not a petition for probate has been filed, at any time before six months have passed since the first appointment of a personal representative under a will; where a later will is offered, the petition against it may be filed until the later of three months after its probate and six months after the first appointment (Md. Code, Est. & Trusts § 5-207(a)(1), (2)).

In Virginia, a person interested in the probate who was not before the court or clerk may file a complaint to impeach or establish the will within one year from the probate order (Va. Code § 64.2-448(A)). The period is two years for a person served by order of publication, and it runs for a minor from majority and for an incapacitated person from restoration of capacity (Va. Code § 64.2-448(B), (C), (D)); a final order determining whether to admit a will bars a later complaint (Va. Code § 64.2-448(G)). Where a presumption of undue influence arises in a will contest, the finder of fact presumes undue influence unless it finds on all the evidence that the decedent intended the document as the will (Va. Code § 64.2-454.1).

Table 1. Forum, time limits and a key rule by jurisdiction

JurisdictionForumTime limitKey rule
Washington DCProbate proceeding; verified complaint with notice to interested personsSix months after published notice of the appointment of a personal representative (D.C. Code § 20-305)Abbreviated probate set aside on a request for formal probate within the same six months (D.C. Code § 20-331(a))
MarylandJudicial probate; a caveat petition operates as a request for itSix months after the first appointment of a personal representative under a will; for a later will, three months after its probate if later (Md. Code, Est. & Trusts § 5-207(a))A caveat filed after judicial probate reopens the matter (Md. Code, Est. & Trusts § 5-207(b)(2))
VirginiaCircuit court; appeal from the clerk’s probate orderAppeal within six months (Va. Code § 64.2-445); complaint within one year of the order, two years if served by publication (Va. Code § 64.2-448(A), (B))Jury trial on whether the document is the will; presumption of undue influence (Va. Code §§ 64.2-448, 64.2-454.1)
GermanyGerman courts for the whole succession under Articles 4 and 10 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012Gifts within ten years before death enter the Pflichtteil computation, reduced by one tenth per year (§ 2325(3) BGB)Pflichtteil of half the value of the intestate share, claimed in money from the heirs (§ 2303 BGB)

Periods are stated as of October 2026 and run from the events named in each statute.

Part V. Forced heirship claims against an estate with US assets

German law protects close family members against disinheritance through a money claim rather than a share of the property. A descendant excluded from the succession by a disposition upon death may demand the Pflichtteil from the heir, and it amounts to half the value of the intestate share; the parents and the spouse have the same right when excluded (§ 2303(1), (2) BGB). Lifetime gifts do not escape the claim: a gift to a third party is added to the estate for the computation, in full if made in the year before death and reduced by one tenth for each further year, and disregarded after ten years; for a gift to the spouse the period does not begin before the marriage is dissolved (§ 2325(1), (3) BGB).

Before a German court, the succession is governed by the law of the State of habitual residence at death unless the deceased chose the law of a State of nationality, and a provision of the applicable law may be refused only where manifestly incompatible with the forum’s public policy (Articles 21(1), 22(1) and 35 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012). A US probate court administering the US assets is not bound by that result and applies its own conflict rules to the property before it. The forced heir’s practical route is therefore a money judgment against the heirs in Germany, followed, where the heirs or the assets are in the United States, by recognition of that judgment under state law (Part VII). Because the Pflichtteil is a claim for a sum of money, the resulting judgment falls within the type of judgment the US recognition statutes address (D.C. Code § 15-363; Va. Code § 8.01-465.13:2).

Part VI. Disputes over trustees and personal representatives

Disputes with fiduciaries usually begin with information. A Virginia trustee must keep the qualified beneficiaries reasonably informed, notify them within sixty days after accepting the trusteeship or after the trust becomes irrevocable, and report on the trust property, receipts, disbursements and compensation at least annually (Va. Code § 64.2-775(A), (B), (C)). Missing or incomplete reports often start the claims about investments and distributions and the petitions for removal.

A personal representative’s accounts serve the same function; in Virginia the inventory is due within four months after the order conferring authority and the first account within sixteen months from qualification (Va. Code §§ 64.2-1300(A), 64.2-1304(A)). Claims against a personal representative often concern the order of payments. A representative who pays other debts or distributes before paying the claims of the United States from an estate that proves insufficient is personally liable to the extent of the payments (31 U.S.C. § 3713(b)), and a settlement paid out of estate assets is such a payment. The fiduciary side of these disputes is set out in Fiduciary Services.

Part VII. Recognition of judgments between Germany and the United States

No treaty between Germany and the United States governs the recognition of court judgments, so each country applies its own rules. In Germany a foreign judgment is not recognized if the foreign courts lacked jurisdiction under German rules, if a defendant who did not appear was not served with the document instituting the proceedings properly and in time to defend, if it conflicts with a German judgment, an earlier recognized foreign judgment or an earlier German proceeding, if recognition would lead to a result manifestly incompatible with essential principles of German law, or if reciprocity is not guaranteed (§ 328(1) ZPO). Reciprocity is not required for a judgment on a non-pecuniary claim where no German court had jurisdiction (§ 328(2) ZPO).

In the United States recognition is a matter of state law. Washington DC and Virginia have adopted the Uniform Foreign-Country Money Judgments Recognition Act, which applies to foreign judgments that grant or deny recovery of a sum of money and are final, conclusive and enforceable where rendered, and excludes judgments for taxes, fines and domestic relations (D.C. Code § 15-363; Va. Code § 8.01-465.13:2). Recognition must be refused where the foreign system lacks impartial tribunals or due process or the court lacked jurisdiction, and may be refused for inadequate notice, fraud or conflict with public policy; reciprocity is not a ground (D.C. Code § 15-364; Va. Code § 8.01-465.13:3). In Virginia the action must be brought within the judgment’s period of effectiveness where rendered and at most fifteen years (Va. Code § 8.01-465.13:8), and judgments outside the statute may still be recognized under principles of comity (Va. Code § 8.01-465.13:10). Maryland’s statute contains its own list of grounds for nonrecognition (Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 10-704).

Two consequences follow. A money judgment, such as one on a Pflichtteil claim, travels more reliably than a judgment declaring heirship or removing a fiduciary, which falls outside the uniform statutes. And because improper service on a defendant who did not appear bars recognition in Germany (§ 328(1) No. 2 ZPO), service there in a US proceeding is planned with recognition in view.

Part VIII. Conducting a dispute in two countries

Such disputes are often decided in their first weeks: by the US deadlines met or missed, the German forum and the form of relief sought.

Practical steps
  1. Calendar the US deadlines at once.

    The periods in Washington DC, Maryland and Virginia run from publication, appointment or the probate order, and heirs abroad are often the last to learn of these events.

  2. Determine the German forum.

    Habitual residence, nationality and the location of assets decide whether German courts hear the whole estate or only the German assets (Articles 4 and 10 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012).

  3. Consider an Article 12 application.

    A party may ask a German court not to rule on US assets where its decision would not be recognized in the United States (Article 12(1)).

  4. Seek relief that will be recognized.

    A money judgment falls under the uniform statutes; in Virginia, declaratory and fiduciary orders depend on comity (Va. Code § 8.01-465.13:10).

  5. Serve with recognition in mind.

    Proper and timely service on a defendant in Germany preserves the later recognition of a US judgment (§ 328(1) No. 2 ZPO).

  6. Treat any settlement payment as a distribution.

    Federal claims are paid or reserved before an estate pays a settlement to an heir (31 U.S.C. § 3713(b)).

How the firm helps

The firm represents heirs, other legatees, personal representatives and trustees in estate-related litigation in the District of Columbia, Virginia, Maryland and Germany.

Most of these disputes arise from the settlement of an estate; the process in Virginia is described in Estate Settlements in Virginia. The duties and liabilities of fiduciaries are treated in Fiduciary Services, and intestate succession under German law in Dying without a Will in Germany.

Law and time limits as of October 2026.

This page is general information as of the date stated and is not legal or tax advice. The application of the rules and conventions described depends on the facts of each case.