Charitable Planning across Borders
Whether a gift to a charity abroad is deductible in the United States depends on the tax concerned, the donor’s citizenship and domicile, the country in which the charity is organized and any applicable treaty.
By Caroline Esche Ashford, PhD, JD · Law stated as of October 2026

Summary.
- The income tax deduction requires a charity created or organized in the United States (I.R.C. § 170(c)(2)(A)); only the income tax treaties with Canada, Mexico and Israel allow a limited deduction for gifts to charities of those countries.
- For a US citizen or domiciliary, the estate and gift tax deductions (I.R.C. §§ 2055, 2522(a)) have no domestic-organization requirement and no percentage limit, so a qualifying charity abroad may receive a deductible bequest or gift directly.
- For a nonresident non-citizen, the estate and gift tax treaties with Germany and France exempt, or allow a full deduction for, qualifying transfers to charities of either country; otherwise the Code confines the deduction to domestic corporations and to trusts for use within the United States (I.R.C. §§ 2106(a)(2), 2522(b)).
- Lifetime giving abroad with an income tax deduction runs through a US organization: a “friends of” organization that controls the funds, a donor-advised fund, or a private foundation making foreign grants.
- A charitable remainder trust must leave its remainder to an organization described in § 170(c), which excludes a charity organized abroad; a nongrantor lead trust may deduct payments to a charity abroad (I.R.C. § 642(c)(1)).
- Germany exempts transfers to German public-benefit bodies from inheritance and gift tax (§ 13(1) no. 16(b) ErbStG); a body abroad qualifies only under letter c, and the treaty clause provides a separate basis for US charities.
Part I. Three US deductions and the location of the charity
US tax law grants a charitable deduction under three separate regimes, the income tax, the estate tax and the gift tax, and each defines the qualifying recipient differently on the point that decides most cross-border cases: whether the charity must be organized in the United States. The answer also depends on the donor, who may be a US citizen, a non-citizen domiciled in the United States, or a nonresident non-citizen taxed only on certain US assets.
Where a treaty addresses charitable transfers, the analysis starts with the treaty. The estate and gift tax treaties with Germany and France contain charitable clauses; the income tax treaties with Canada, Mexico and Israel allow a deduction for gifts to charities of the treaty partner. Otherwise the Code governs.
Which US deduction or treaty exemption applies, by donor and recipient
| Donor and tax | Charity organized in the United States | Charity organized abroad | Governing rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income tax, any donor (I.R.C. § 170) | Deductible within the percentage limits | Not deductible, unless the treaty with Canada, Mexico or Israel applies | Domestic-organization requirement (§ 170(c)(2)(A)) |
| Estate tax, citizen or domiciliary (I.R.C. § 2055) | Deductible without percentage limit | Deductible without percentage limit if it meets the US standard | Treas. Reg. § 20.2055-1(a) |
| Gift tax, citizen or domiciliary (I.R.C. § 2522(a)) | Deductible without percentage limit | Deductible without percentage limit if it meets the US standard | Treas. Reg. § 25.2522(a)-1(a) |
| Estate tax, nonresident non-citizen domiciled in Germany or France | Deductible as a transfer to a domestic corporation | Exempt if the treaty conditions are met | Article 10(2) of the treaty with Germany; Article 10 of the treaty with France |
| Estate tax, other nonresident non-citizen (I.R.C. § 2106(a)(2)) | Deductible for a domestic corporation, or a trust for use within the United States | Not deductible | Non-US gross estate must be stated on the return (§ 2106(b)) |
| Gift tax, nonresident non-citizen (I.R.C. § 2522(b)) | Deductible for a domestic corporation, or a trust for use within the United States | Not deductible under the Code | Treas. Reg. § 25.2522(b)-1 |
A charity organized abroad must in every case be organized and operated exclusively for charitable purposes by the US standard; the treaty clauses add conditions of their own.
Part II. The income tax deduction and the treaty exceptions
Where the donor has income from Canada, Mexico or Israel, the treaty with that country comes first. Contributions to qualifying Canadian charities are deductible within the US percentage limits applied to the donor’s Canadian-source income, and without such income generally not at all; gifts to a Canadian college or university at which the donor or a family member is or was enrolled are excepted from the source limitation (IRS Publication 597, on Article XXI of the treaty). For Mexican and Israeli charities the donor needs income from that country and the limits are computed on it; for Israel the deduction is further capped at 25 percent of Israeli-source adjusted gross income (IRS Publication 526).
In every other case a deductible contribution must go to an organization created or organized in the United States or under the law of the United States, a State, the District of Columbia or a possession (I.R.C. § 170(c)(2)(A)). A German, Swiss or British charity does not qualify, however closely its purposes match, and a contribution to a US organization that is earmarked for a foreign organization is not deductible either (IRS Publication 526).
Part III. Estate and gift tax deductions for citizens and domiciliaries
The estate tax deduction is drafted differently. It covers transfers to any corporation organized and operated exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, literary or educational purposes that meets the conditions on private inurement, lobbying and political campaigns, and transfers to trustees for such purposes (I.R.C. § 2055(a)(2), (3)). Neither provision requires a domestic recipient or use in the United States, as the regulations confirm (Treas. Reg. § 20.2055-1(a)). There is no percentage ceiling; the deduction is limited to the value of the property included in the gross estate (I.R.C. § 2055(d)).
The gift tax deduction of a citizen or resident is equally free of any domestic requirement (I.R.C. § 2522(a)(2); Treas. Reg. § 25.2522(a)-1(a)). A direct lifetime gift to a charity abroad earns no income tax deduction but uses none of the donor’s basic exclusion amount. For a substantial gift to a charity abroad the will or revocable trust is therefore the efficient instrument.
The latitude concerns the location of the charity, not its character. A body recognized as charitable at home can still fail the US standard, for example through political activity lawful in its own country. The deduction is claimed on Schedule O of Form 706, and the supporting file is best assembled when the will is drafted.
Part IV. Nonresident non-citizens: the treaty clauses and the Code
A donor who is neither a US citizen nor domiciled in the United States is subject to US estate tax only on US-situs assets. For a decedent domiciled in Germany, the treaty governs first: property transferred to a corporation or organization of either country serving exclusively religious, charitable, scientific, educational or public purposes, or to a public body of either country, is exempt from tax in the other country if and to the extent the transfer is exempt in the first country and would be exempt in the other if made to a similar organization there (Article 10(2) of the estate and gift tax treaty with Germany). A German-domiciled decedent’s bequest of a US residence to a German charitable foundation can therefore pass free of US estate tax, although the Code alone would deny the deduction.
The estate and gift tax treaty with France contains a comparable clause: a transfer to an entity of one country is exempt, or fully deductible, in the other if it would have qualified had the entity been organized there, provided the entity is exempt at home, is organized and operated exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, literary, educational or cultural purposes, and receives a substantial part of its support from the public or from government funds (Article 10 of the treaty with France, as amended by the protocol of December 8, 2004). French counsel advises on the French side.
Where no treaty clause applies, the estate of a nonresident non-citizen may deduct transfers to US governmental bodies for public purposes, to a domestic corporation organized and operated exclusively for charitable purposes, or to trustees, in the last case only for use within the United States (I.R.C. § 2106(a)(2)(A)). The deduction requires the return to state the value of the gross estate situated outside the United States (I.R.C. § 2106(b)), and the Form 706-NA instructions require a treaty-based deduction to name the treaty and attach a computation. Lifetime gifts follow the same geography (I.R.C. § 2522(b); Treas. Reg. § 25.2522(b)-1).
Two responses follow for donors without a treaty clause: assets situated outside the United States are outside the US estate tax, so the missing deduction costs nothing; and US-situs assets can be left to a domestic corporation that supports the foreign cause.
Part V. US vehicles for giving abroad
“Friends of” organizations
A domestic charity formed to support a foreign institution is itself a US organization, and contributions to it are deductible if it is not a conduit. A contribution for use in a program of a foreign charity may be deductible where the US organization has approved the program as furthering its own exempt purposes and keeps control over the funds, and also where the foreign charity is only an administrative arm of the US organization (IRS Publication 526). The US board must therefore be free to decline a donor’s stated preference.
Donor-advised funds
A donor-advised fund is held by a US sponsoring organization; the donor’s deduction arises on the contribution, and the grant abroad is the sponsor’s act. A distribution to a natural person is always a taxable distribution; a distribution to any other recipient, apart from an organization described in § 170(b)(1)(A), the sponsor or another such fund, is taxable unless it serves a charitable purpose and the sponsor exercises expenditure responsibility under § 4945(h). The sponsor owes a 20 percent excise tax on a taxable distribution (I.R.C. § 4966(a)(1), (c)).
Private foundations
A US private foundation may make a grant to a foreign organization without an IRS determination letter on the basis of a good-faith determination, made on the written advice of a qualified tax practitioner, that the grantee is equivalent to a US public charity (Treas. Reg. § 53.4945-5(a)(5); Rev. Proc. 2017-53). Otherwise it must exercise expenditure responsibility: reasonable steps to ensure proper use of the grant, full reports from the grantee and reports to the IRS (I.R.C. § 4945(h)); a grant without either is a taxable expenditure (I.R.C. § 4945(d)(4)).
Part VI. Charitable remainder and lead trusts with beneficiaries abroad
Where a charity and family members share the same property, the deduction is available only for a charitable remainder annuity trust or unitrust or pooled income fund, or for a guaranteed annuity or fixed-percentage interest (I.R.C. §§ 170(f)(2), 2055(e)(2)).
Charitable remainder trusts
A charitable remainder trust pays an annuity or unitrust amount of between 5 and 50 percent for not more than 20 years or for the lives of individuals living at its creation, and the remainder, valued under § 7520, must be at least 10 percent of the value contributed (I.R.C. § 664(d)(1), (2)); the trust is exempt from income tax (I.R.C. § 664(c)(1)). The Code imposes no citizenship or residence requirement on the individual beneficiaries, so a child living abroad may receive the payments, which carry out ordinary income first, then capital gain, other income and corpus (I.R.C. § 664(b)).
The remainder is the cross-border constraint. It must pass to, or be held for the use of, an organization described in § 170(c) (I.R.C. § 664(d)(1)(C); Treas. Reg. § 1.664-2(a)(6)), which a charity organized abroad is not. A foreign cause is reached by naming a supporting US organization as remainder beneficiary.
Charitable lead trusts
A charitable lead trust pays the charity first and the family later. In grantor form, the donor’s income tax deduction (I.R.C. § 170(f)(2)(B)) is subject to the domestic-organization requirement. In nongrantor form, the trust deducts its charitable payments, and the statute applies the purpose test of § 170(c) without regard to that requirement (I.R.C. § 642(c)(1)). For a citizen or domiciliary, the estate or gift tax deduction for the charity’s interest follows §§ 2055 and 2522 and is not limited to US charities. The nongrantor lead trust is thus the form in which a charity abroad can be the current beneficiary.
Part VII. The German side: inheritance and gift tax
Where the donor or estate is within German inheritance and gift tax, transfers to German bodies that, under their articles and actual management, serve exclusively and directly church, public-benefit or charitable purposes within §§ 52 to 54 of the Fiscal Code are exempt; the exemption lapses retroactively if the body ceases to qualify within ten years and the property is not applied to qualifying purposes (§ 13(1) no. 16(b) ErbStG). Transfers dedicated exclusively to such purposes are also exempt where that use is secured (§ 13(1) no. 17 ErbStG).
A body outside Germany qualifies under letter c only if it is of the same kind, would be exempt from German corporate income tax if it had German income, and is located in a state bound by treaty to give Germany exchange of information on inheritance tax to the OECD standard and assistance in collection; the Federal Ministry of Finance publishes a list of qualifying third countries. Where its purposes are pursued only abroad, persons resident in Germany must benefit or the activity must be able to contribute to the standing of Germany (§ 13(1) no. 16(c) ErbStG).
For a transfer to a US charity, the treaty clause provides a separate basis: the transfer is exempt from German tax if it is exempt in the United States and would be exempt in Germany if made to a comparable German organization (Article 10(2) of the estate and gift tax treaty with Germany). The exemption is claimed in the German return.
- Establish the donor’s status first
Confirm citizenship, domicile and the applicable treaty; the same bequest can be deductible for one family member and not for another.
- Decide which tax the gift is to reduce
An income tax deduction requires a US recipient or one of the three treaties; the estate and gift tax deductions of a citizen or domiciliary reach a qualifying charity abroad directly.
- Test the charity against the US standard
Obtain its governing documents, evidence of its activities and proof of its exemption at home, and keep them for Schedule O.
- Claim the treaty clause expressly
For a decedent domiciled in Germany or France, name the treaty article on Form 706-NA and attach the required computation.
- Choose trust beneficiaries with the deduction rules in view
Name a US organization as remainder beneficiary; where a charity abroad is to be the current beneficiary, use a nongrantor lead trust.
- Confirm the treatment in the charity’s country
Check the German exemption, or the exemption elsewhere with advisers there, before the will or trust is signed.
How the firm helps
Ashford International Law PC advises on how best to leave assets to charities, in the United States and abroad, as part of the estate plan as a whole: the domicile and situs analysis for non-US citizens living in the United States and for nonresidents with US assets, the drafting of charitable bequests and split-interest trusts, and the position under the treaties with Germany and France.
With attorneys licensed in Washington DC, Virginia, Maryland, California and Germany, the firm addresses the German exemption together with the US analysis. For charities in France it advises on the American side and on the France-US treaties, with French counsel from its network on the French side; elsewhere it works with the client’s own advisers. Related questions are covered under gift planning across borders and trusts.
Law and figures as of October 2026.
This page is general information as of the date stated and is not legal or tax advice. The application of the rules and conventions described depends on the facts of each case.



